The Cayuga Nation has acquired land next to the Finger Lakes Drive-In in the town of Aurelius 鈥 and effectively closed the outdoor movie theater, saying it encroaches upon that land.
But the owner of the drive-in, who is a defendant in a separate federal lawsuit filed by the nation, claims there are ulterior motives behind the closure.听
In a news release Thursday, the nation's leadership council said it has acquired 40.18 acres of land at 1044 Clark St. Road, west of the drive-in. According to Cayuga County property , the nation purchased the residential property for $720,000 from previous owner Joseph Elice in January 2023. Its total assessed value at the time was $56,000.
An investigation by the nation then concluded that the drive-in's main entrance and several parking spots, as well as about a third of its movie screen, are located on the property, it said Thursday.
Because the nation has submitted an application to the U.S. Department of the Interior to place its new land into federal trust, it filed a complaint in Cayuga County Supreme Court on Tuesday seeking to confirm the property line between that land and the drive-in. The nation said it has communicated with the drive-in about the encroachment, but the issue has not been resolved.听
"Defendants continue to operate their Finger Lakes Drive-In on part of the nation's property, without authorization, and under the claim of an entirely invalid lease and a dispute over the boundary line," the complaint says. "When the nation has raised this illegal conduct to defendants and demanded they vacate the property, defendants have refused."听
In its news release, the nation added that it "acknowledges that many from the neighboring community patronize the Finger Lakes Drive-In and (is) hopeful about a resolution." According to its complaint, the nation seeks a declaration of its ownership of the land, a judgment holding the drive-in liable for trespassing with monetary damages, and an order ejecting the drive-in from the land.
Last fall, the nation听placed听its first Cayuga County properties into federal trust following the听approval听of its 20-year-old application to do so by the Bureau of Indian Affairs in March.听
鈥淭his 40-acre parcel is squarely within the land the federal government reserved to the nation in the Treaty of Canandaigua," said Clint Halftown, the nation's federally recognized representative. "The nation is committed to strategic purchases to reacquire the land within its reservation and will continue placing lands in trust with the Bureau of Indian Affairs when appropriate.鈥
However, neither the news release nor the complaint mention that the owner of the drive-in, Paul Meyer, is also a defendant in a federal lawsuit the nation听filed in spring 2022 against smoke shop Pipekeepers at 7153 Route 90 in the town of Montezuma. Meyer sold that property to operator Dusty Parker after the nation forcibly evicted him from the previous Seneca Falls location of Pipekeepers.
A judge dismissed two of the $15 million lawsuit's three counts in September 2022, and the remaining count is currently in discovery.
Also, in 2016, Meyer gave Parker a parcel behind the drive-in to operate what the nation's leadership council called a "rogue smoke shop." It closed days later amid legal action by the town of Aurelius.
Meyer did not respond to a request for comment by 水果派AV. But the drive-in a GoFundMe on Thursday, seeking to raise $125,000 for a legal fund in order to save the outdoor movie theater from closure by the nation. The nation has placed concrete barricades in the main entrance of the drive-in, whose season traditionally begins in late spring.
Noting that the drive-in signed a 20-year lease for the parcel in 2014, the fundraiser page accuses Halftown of "knowingly" purchasing the parcel for an "inflated" amount. The page also calls for a boycott of Cayuga Nation businesses in Union Springs and Seneca Falls. As of Friday morning the fundraiser has collected $250, including $100 from Meyer.